Sarahs Key Book Review

Sarah’s Key by Tatiana de Rosnay Book Review

Although Sarah’s Key is over a decade old, it seems fairly new – as if I first heard about it the other day. It’s been on my to-read list for years but try as I might, I can’t possibly dent that continually growing pile without major life changes, a lottery win, a nanny, and limitless time on my hands. Thankfully, before Sarah’s Key was lost to the netherworld of my impossible to-read list, I was given a copy for Christmas. No more excuses. St. Martins Paperbacks | September, 2016 (first published 2006) | Paperback | 368 pp

Sarah’s Key provides alternating story lines in different eras. In one story, we follow young Sarah Starzynski in 1942 Paris during the infamous roundup of Parisian Jews under German occupation. The other follows Julia Jarmond in present day. She’s an American journalist living in Paris who became curious about the roundup when her magazine asked her to write about the sixtieth commemoration of the Vel’ d’Hiv, a giant stadium where the Jews were held in inhumane conditions before being transferred to Auschwitz or other camps to be gassed.

Sarah was only ten when the police came for her family. It wasn’t the Nazis but their own French policeman who rounded them up with little sympathy (as described in the book). Sarah didn’t really know what would happen because her family didn’t talk about it. She assumed that they would be back, so she locked her younger brother in a secret cupboard promising to return. She was taken to Vel’ d’Hiv with her mother and father and for days they languished without food or drink. Each moment that passed was agony; she could only think about her brother locked in the cupboard. Would he get out? Would he survive? Would he forgive her for not being able to come back?

In present day, Julia Jarmond learns more about the roundup and grows increasingly upset about the event. As her husband renovates the apartment that his family had owned for generations, she learns that his grandmother and grandfather had moved into that apartment in 1942, when there was a sudden availability of apartments created by the Jewish roundup. She instantly knew that a Jewish family had lived there. After being asked to stop looking into the matter, her father-in-law breaks down, and says that he will never forget the little girl who broke out of the camp and came to his new apartment – Sarah Starzynki. She haunted him.

It becomes a quest for Julia. She must know – what happened to Sarah?

While I knew about the roundup, I didn’t know many of the details, including the use of the Vel’ d’Hiv which was a stadium used for sports before it was turned internment camp. Thousands of Jews were packed into this stadium and in July, the heat must have been oppressive. It was unsanitary and little food and water were provided. Many died in the stadium, which was probably a blessing. After days of horrid conditions, they were then packed into cattle cars and sent to one of several camps just outside of Paris. These were secondary holding camps and from there, they were packed again into cattle cars and sent to the death camps in Poland for mass executions by gas. What happened at these secondary camps was truly horrific – something I didn’t know about: the parents were separated from the children and sent first to their deaths while the children were left alone, starving, and frightened in these camps.

An elderly local shares his horrific memory in the book:

“And one day, there was a noise. An awful noise. My parents used to live a distance from the camp. But we still heard it. A roar that went through the entire town. Went on all day. I heard my parents talking to the neighbors. That were saying that the mothers had been separated from the children, back at the camp.”

It had been the wailing of parents.

A theme in both story lines is the disbelief that local Parisians and police force had participated in the roundup while many stood by and looked in the other direction. People and historians that Julia spoke to kept referring to is as a great shame. She couldn’t believe that her husband’s family had moved into that apartment knowing full well that it had been recently vacated because of the roundup. While I would like to share in her admonishment, I couldn’t help but feel slightly defensive – and I’m not even French.

France was under German occupation. The Nazis were hanging people in the street thought to be Jewish sympathizers or part of the resistance every day. And many of these good Parisians did what they could through small acts of subterfuge. They knew the cost of getting caught helping, or not following orders: immediate execution. Most of the men were already gone and in POW camps in Germany – or killed. Paris was mostly filled with women, children, and the elderly. There was only so much that could be done under the killing machine occupation. For most, this was not something they wanted to go along with and yet I found the book to be highly accusatory.

I was far more interested in Sarah’s story, but I learned a lot from Julia’s research. A gut-wrenching book on the Jewish roundup in occupied France – if you plan on reading, get the tissues.

Sarah’s Key
by Tatiana de Rosnay

Sarah's Key

Rebecca Skane

Rebecca Skane is the editor-in-chief for the Portsmouth Review. She holds a Bachelor of the Arts degree from Lawrence University in Wisconsin and resides in Portsmouth, NH with her husband and two children. She is the founder of The Portsmouth Book Club which boasts over 1,000 members. She also doubles as a professional escapist.Her genres are scifi and fantasy, both adult and young adult - but she often reads outside of her preferred genres. You can follow her on GoodReads.Aside from her love of good books, she is a professional website developer, content editor, and SEO expert. You can visit her web design and development site at

  • Nice review. I think I was about to read this novel when the movie of it came out and then I saw that instead, but I should go back and read it too. The movie of it is quite good with Kristin Scott Thomas, who was also in Suite Francaise, another Paris Occupation book. I can see where people in such a situation would never be able to forgive others or each other after the war.

    • I had no idea there was a movie. Of course there was a move. 🙂 I think I might just check it out.

  • I thought this was new as well. I’ve seen it around and have contemplated on whether or not I should get but I wasn’t interested enough, I guess. You are very convincing in your review, though. So I might scour for a copy on my thrift store haunts. I am interested in the period, though.

    • It’s definitely worth the read. Between the two story lines though, I enjoyed the WWII time period more. It was so very emotional and gut-wrenching.

  • I didn’t know about this one (or the movie), but it sounds like an intriguing (and highly emotional) read. Definitely worth a read! Thanks for the review!

    • Very emotional, as all Holocaust and WWII books tend to be. I haven’t seen the movie yet but I plan on it now. 🙂

  • I don’t know if this is for me. I know I’ll get so angry because I see so much potential of it happening again. I also understand the accusatory nature of the book but I can also understand that perhaps the anger should have been more productive in things that could have changed or made a difference.

    • I see the potential for a recurrence as well. Scary times. I think I liked The Nightingale better since it showed how hard the French people worked to subvert the Nazis.

  • Oh man. I teared up just reading this review! Very well done. I love books like this because they tell such moving stories and they keep important events like this in our minds. Without the reminders, I firmly believe this sort of terrible event could happen again. That said, I am not one to pick up a book like this lightly. I like to read for fun, and being sad isn’t my idea of fun.
    Thank you for reviewing this, Rebecca– it might not be added to my TBR, but I appreciate the existence of Sarah’s Key.

    • I know what you mean. I also read for enjoyment – but I do have an addiction to WWII books which are almost always sad.

© Copyright 2017 The Portsmouth Review - All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

Visit Us On FacebookVisit Us On Google PlusCheck Our Feed